Many users are wondering which is better - a humidifier or an air wash. Recently, climate technology is gaining popularity, which is justified by the desire of a person to maintain the most comfortable atmosphere in his home. Let's try to figure out how the two types of equipment differ, what are their advantages and disadvantages.
Air wash
To understand which is better - a humidifier or a sink of air, you should study the design features of both devices. Let's start with the second option. It is a multifunctional climate equipment that does not require additional consumables. The market offers two types of devices:
- Version with rotating drum and filter discs.
- Model with conical circulation supercharger.
Household air washers operate with wet discs. The principle of operation of the units under consideration is as follows:
- the introduced fan draws air from the room and delivers it to the inside of the device;
- the disks in the drum are systematically wetted by the liquid in the equipment pan;
- in contact with water, the air is cleaned, followed by settling of wool, hair and dust, polluting the atmosphere.
What is the difference between air washing and humidifier? Firstly, even the most inexpensive versions of sinks are equipped with a hygrometer. In other versions, it is possible to install a humidity controller for air flow. Upon reaching the set degree, the device automatically stops working.
Circulation supercharger
When choosing an air cleaner or an ultrasonic humidifier, you should pay attention to the circulation type supercharger. It is equipped with a fan that creates a multi-level liquid curtain. Air under pressure seeps through small droplets of water, clearing of harmful and extraneous impurities. The equipment in question is sometimes equipped with ultraviolet lamps, which additionally disinfect the incoming stream. In addition, an ionizer can be mounted in the system.
Humidifiers
How to understand which is better - air washing or humidifier (ultrasonic)? For this, it is worth considering the design features of the second unit. There are three types of modifications on the modern market:
- Cold hydration.
- Steam effect.
- Ultrasound.
The difference between a humidifier and an air sink lies in the fact that the devices in question serve only to stabilize the humidity level, when the sinks additionally clean the atmosphere from pollution. The second type of equipment, along with the improvement of functionality, has a great cost.
The principle of operation of devices with hot humidification consists in the formation of steam, gradually filling the working area. This modification does not provide for water heating; the fan contributes to the distribution of steam in equal quantities. The batch feed in the operation of the equipment increases the efficiency of the device and provides energy savings.
Cold hydration
Considering which is better - a humidifier or a sink of air, it is necessary to pay attention to devices with a cold operating principle. These devices achieve the required humidity by natural evaporation of the liquid. To distribute better and more correctly, water is placed in special absorbent sponges.
The fan, creating an atmospheric flow, speeds up the evaporation process, evenly distributing the vapors throughout the entire room. If the specified parameter is not enough, the propeller is more active until the desired value is reached.
Ultrasound
Which is better - an air wash or an ultrasonic humidifier? The answer to this question can be found by studying the design features and actions of the last device. It includes the following elements:
- ceramic membranes;
- metal electrodes;
- electrical wiring.
After power is applied, the membrane begins to vibrate, which provokes the creation of waves of a certain frequency. Next, the liquid is converted into an aerosol composition with the smallest sedimentary particles. A fan pushes water out of the machine.
Air Wash: Unlike a Humidifier
Units combining the options for washing the air and the humidifier are called climate complexes. For example, ultrasound systems can perform several functions simultaneously:
- ionization;
- disinfection;
- flavoring.
According to consumer feedback, this model is considered the best option in terms of price and quality.
Definition
When choosing an air cleaner or ultrasonic humidifier, pay attention to the following parameters:
- conditions of tasks and goals aimed at normalizing the climate in a particular room;
- overall dimensions of the unit;
- installation method;
- cost.
Living rooms are best treated with an air wash combined with a humidifier. Special storage or similar compartments can be serviced with a composition that combines drying and humidification. Public reception rooms and similar facilities are predominantly served by high-performance industrial systems.
Manufacturers Overview
The rating of sinks and humidifiers is given below. Sink "Atmos-2652" is one of the best units of domestic production. The device belongs to the middle price segment, has a modern exterior and ease of operation. The electronic controller aggregates, coupled with a capacious working tank (4.2 l). The flow rate of the emulsifier leaves about 250 ml / hour.
An ultrasonic atomizer has several advantages over competitors, namely:
- high build quality;
- reasonable price;
- economical energy consumption parameter;
- low noise during operation.
The minuses include a short cable length. The average price is from four thousand rubles.
Boneco W2055 DR
This device is designed to purify and humidify the air at the same time. The device has a visually pleasing black glossy case and electronic control. A liquid crystal monitor is located on the front panel, onto which hygrometer data is displayed. The device is focused on rooms with an area of not more than 50 square meters.
Advantages of the low noise device:
- fluid level support in the pan;
- low noise figure (not higher than 25 dB);
- honeycomb drive configuration;
- built-in flavor.
Users of this unit did not find any special flaws, except for the price, which is from 25 thousand rubles.
EHAW-9015D mini
In solving the dilemma, which is better - a humidifier or air washing, you should pay attention to the mini-device from the company "Electrolux". It is suitable for use in rooms not exceeding an area of 20 square meters. The device has a concise and modern design, three power modes. The design provides protection against children, as well as an indication of the water level and automatic blocking in the absence thereof.
The pros include such moments:
- affordable cost along with decent quality;
- profitability;
- the presence of a timer with a break of 60 minutes;
- hygrometer;
- turn off the backlight at night or if necessary;
- lamp function.
Among the minuses is the bright illumination of the monitor, which sometimes dazzles. The price of the device is around 10 thousand rubles.
Winia AWX-70
Spectacular and stylish air cleaning is aimed at maintaining the perfect microclimate in rooms up to 50 square meters. The version is available in four colors, equipped with special filtering elements, and also has an adjustable fan speed.
In addition to having an indicator of the liquid level and the degree of contamination of the filters, the machine has the following advantages:
- aromatization and ionization option;
- high rate of performance;
- switching power modes.
By cons, consumers and experts include the large dimensions of the product and the cost, which starts from 21 thousand rubles.
What are the differences?
What is the difference between washing an air and a humidifier? In fact, these devices are very similar in operation and design. Their work is aimed at stabilizing the internal climate atmosphere. Many people noticed that after the start of the heating season the air in the apartment becomes much drier, which negatively affects the well-being and health of the residents.
Among the negative factors of such an impact, the following is noted:
- general fatigue, drowsiness, headaches, dry skin;
- visual impairment and redness of the cornea, especially when working at a computer;
- the formation of a suspension of the smallest particles of dust, which increases the risk of allergies and respiratory diseases.
It is worth noting that people working in such an environment (archivists, librarians) are more susceptible to respiratory diseases than others.
Total
Which is better - a humidifier or a sink of air? Reviews indicate that for humidification of small rooms, including children's rooms, an ultrasonic humidifier will be the best option. If you need to process a large area or several compartments - pay attention to the air wash, with which you can moisten and disinfect up to 100 square meters in one cycle.